Friday, February 15, 2008

On the Rise of Irrationalism

As economy emerged from the economic interactions of people, it had the effect of encouraging more rational, economic thinking among people. Thus, it is not that man is Homo economus, as economists think, but that free markets make us more likely to act in more economic-rational ways. Since we remain social mammals, we will never be rid of our social rules of behavior which constrain our rationalist behavior. The irony is that as markets made man more rational, we began to think that using reason would be the best way to transform the world, that it could be rationally ordered and organized. The result was the rise of ideas of economic planning based on a rationalist model, giving rise to various forms of socialism. The irony being that, without free markets, the pressure on people to think rationally is released, so that socialism leads us directly back to nonrationalist thinking, and the very foundations originally claimed for having a planned economy are undermined. Faced with this, those who fundamentally support socialism turned away from rationalism, leading to the rise of postmodernism. Thus did rationalism undermine itself, not knowing its origins.

2 comments:

John said...

Why do free markets encourage us to think more rationally? How is socialism categorically irrational?

I'm not saying I disagree with you. I'd just like to hear more.

Troy Camplin said...

In a free market, rational behavior is rewarded and irrational behavior is punished. Under socialism, you aren't punished for being irrational, so more people in society can act irrational without consequence. The arational market creates rational behavior, while the "rationally designed" socialist economy creates irrational behavior among those in the society. Everyone is ostensibly taken care of under socialism, even when people act like idiots and fools.